Tuesday, February 3, 2009

Competitive Bikejoring Versus Scootering



I think bikejoring as a competitive sport is ridiculous. The profound mechanical advantage of the bicycle almost negates the power of the dogs. I can put a Chihuahua in a basket on my bike and win bikejor races simply by riding as fast as I can. I would not have to brake on the descents to check the speed of my dogs if the course was rough. I would be able to bomb downhills and at the finish, let out the Chihuahua to cross the line in front so I don't break the rules. Unless the course is all climbing then a team of good dogs will just slow me down. Bikejoring is great for training dogs but if you are allowed to pedal then the sport becomes a lot less sporting. When I train dogs on a bike I pedal as little as possible because my objective is to work my team.
I have a long history with bicycles. I raced road bikes during the late 1970s until the mid 1980s. I then changed my emphasis to mountain bikes and raced mountain bikes into the early 1990s. When I took up skijoring and bikejoring I phased out the bike racing in my life. I feel equally comfortable on a bike or a scooter when running dogs.
Scootering is a much more dog powered sport for competition. Pedaling a scooter has no profound mechanical advantage like a bicycle has. The person who wins a scooter race is a lot more likely to have had good dogs. The winner of a bikejoring race might have good dogs but you can't be sure because the rider may have had a slack line during the whole race.
The popularity of bikejoring races is growing. The reason is that many people already own a bike and use it to train dogs. Far fewer people own a scooter. I would like for more competitive dog drivers invest in a scooter. I would like all race giving organisations to emphasize the scooter class as the pro class for one or two dogs and make the bikejoring class a novice class. Racing dogs should be all about the dogs and not the rig. Pedaling a bike while racing is eqivilant to using a motor on your ATV when training a team of dogs.

4 comments:

Dani&Landy said...

Hello Mike,we are a spanish marriage that practise mushing here.We like a lot of your dogs.You can see our dogs in our blog.
Greetings!

deltafour1212 said...

Totaly agree with your assesmant

Mike Simpson said...

I totally disagree with your assessment. (And I can spell too.) Bikejoring is far more functional than scootering. You can go farther, faster on a bike with a dog. Or 2. Far and Wide. Bikes can go many more places than a scooter. Bike can go over and through things where a scooter does not stand a chance. Function and Fun. Mushing is rooted in function. Team-Work. Dog and Human.

DryDock said...

Take the chain off for competitions. Who wants to buy a one use scooter.